Have you ever wondered how the rates that a public utility charges its customers are set? This article provides a brief overview and some insight into the process of setting customer rates in the state of Hawai‘i for a utility. It does not attempt to touch on every major section of a rate case but instead focuses on giving a cursory overview of a few of the major points in determining how a utility obtains a rate increase through a rate case. Some of these steps and processes may be different depending on the size and/or industry of the utility.
Regulatory Compact
The key concept to understanding utility regulation is understanding the rights and obligations of utilities and their customers. The “regulatory compact” requires that a public utility provide safe, reliable utility service at fair and reasonable prices to anyone in its service territory. The utility generally does not have a right to choose its customer – anyone in the utility’s service territory willing to pay for service has a right to obtain such service. In return, the utility is afforded (1) a service territory that is theoretically free from competition, (2) the right to use public rights of way and easements, (3) the power of condemnation and eminent domain to obtain the assets the utility needs to provide service, and (4) the right to earn a fair and reasonable rate of return on the utility’s investment. This does not mean that the utility is guaranteed to make the granted rate of return but that the utility is allowed to set its rates at a level in which the utility has the opportunity to earn the rate of return set by the Commission.
Rate Regulation
As previously mentioned, a utility’s customers are entitled to service at “fair and reasonable prices” while at the same time the utility is entitled to a fair and reasonable return on its investment in exchange. While there are many ways that the Public Utilities Commission (the “Commission”) can impact a utility’s return on investment, one of the more significant processes comes in the form of a rate case. A rate case, as the name implies, is the process whereby the Commission determines the rates that a utility is allowed to charge its customers for the service rendered by the utility to that customer. From the utility’s perspective, the object of the rate case is to obtain the total amount of revenue (known as the “Revenue Requirements”) needed by the utility to cover the cost to the utility (including a reasonable rate of return on the utility’s investment) of providing service to its customers.
In its simplest form, the Revenue Requirements formula used in a rate case is:
Revenue Requirements = operating expenses1 + (rate base2 x cost of capital3)
Once Revenue Requirements are determined, the rate increase afforded to a utility through a rate case can be shown as:
Rate increase = Revenue Requirements – Revenues at current effective rates prior to the rate case
The final part of a typical rate case involves allocating the increase among the utility’s various classes of customers to determine the actual rates per unit (i.e., kilowatthour, therm, gallon etc.) charged to the customer in a process called rate design/cost of service. The unit cost is developed by allocating the rate increase among the various customer classes and dividing each class by the estimated unit sales for that class. Each class of customer does not necessarily pay the same rate for the same service as there may be public policy or other reasons why there are different rates between the various classes of customers.4 Theoretically, a properly designed rate increase will give the utility an opportunity to earn its allowed rate of return on its investment.
Determining When to File a Rate Case
The decision to file a general rate increase application is generally dictated by the current and projected financial need of the utility.5 The utility must choose between (1) filing early enough to anticipate attrition in earnings, new capital additions, or known cost increases (with the result that earnings for the 12 months prior to filing may not appear to justify the requested increase), and (2) filing later when the need for relief will be more apparent to the Commission but the delay in receiving a rate increase (known as regulatory lag) will result in a significant drop in a utility’s earnings in the interim period prior to the receipt of the requested relief. Other considerations include the commitment of time and energy by the utility to the rate case, the impact of the filing date on the test year, the strategic plan of the utility to start major capital expenditure programs and other endeavors such as significant cost reduction efforts, and the balance of frequent rate case filing, even yearly, for small increases (which requires more utility resources and may irritate the Commission) and filing less frequently for larger increases (which may antagonize consumers and trigger a legislative response to the rate increases).
Resources Required for a Rate Case
A properly filed rate case application and the subsequent process is an enormous commitment in time and energy for a utility, the Commission and any other parties, such as a consumer advocate, involved in the proceeding.
Once a utility decides to file a rate case application, the utility needs to select employees from the utility as witnesses who will be assisting throughout the entire proceeding.6 The utility should also determine to what extent outside experts should be used to addresses specific areas such as rate of return, accounting issues and other technical issues.
In conjunction with the selection of witnesses, the utility must determine its sales, expenses and capital expenditures over a future test period (typically a year) and put together the application to be filed with the Commission.7 This process may take a utility over six months to complete and will involve many different departments of the utility. There are many steps involved between the filing of an application and the decision from the Commission, such as filing testimony exhibits and supporting work papers, discovery requests for information, evidentiary hearing, and filing of briefs on the issues. It may be over a year before final rates for a utility are set and it may be even longer if there are any appeals of the Commission decision.
Outcome of a Rate Case
How the Commission will rule on any particular rate case is uncertain. However, a utility can increase its chances for success by remembering three points: first, the burden of proving that the utility is entitled to a rate increase rests on the utility (thus, if a utility is not entitled to a rate increase, it should not be asking for an increase); second, the reasonableness of the utility’s rate request, the credibility of the utility and its witnesses as well as the cooperation of the utility, both historically and in the rate case, will have a tremendous impact on the outcome of the rate case;8 and third, a utility should view a rate case as an opportunity to educate the Commission as to the industry the utility is in, what the utility does, and the utility’s goals and mission. The greatest obstacles to timely and favorable actions are a lack of understanding by the Commission of the utility and a mistrust of the utility as to its motivations by the parties.
While all of the components of revenue requirements are constantly increasing or decreasing, it is common for a few components of revenue requirements to create the need for a rate case. For example, major investments in utility plant such as a new generating unit, construction of a new water well may drive a rate case as the utility seeks to add the significant investment into its rate base in determining a fair rate of return on investment. In addition, every case is affected by changes in inflation, interest rates, and the state of the economy.
1 Operating expenses are those expenses necessary to operate the utility. Some of the categories that may appear in a rate case (depending on the type of utility) are fuel expense, purchased power expense, production operation and maintenance expenses, transmission and distribution operation and maintenance expenses, customer accounts expense, customer service expense, taxes, depreciation and amortization expense, and administrative and general expense.
2 Rate base is simply the utility investors’ net investment in the utility. Rate base is calculated using plant in service (less accumulated depreciation) as adjusted for other items depending on whether such items are deemed to use investor funds. For example, deferred taxes, customer advances, customer deposits working cash generally are deductions from rate base as the funds used by the utility are not supplied by the investor. Additions to rate base include material and supplies inventories, other inventories, and other assets that use investor funds. The net amount of the rate base is used to calculate the fair rate of return.
3 The fair rate of return should at least be equal to a utility’s composite cost of capital, which is equal to the carrying cost of the money received from investors to finance the net rate base. The composite cost of capital is the sum of the weighted effective cost of each element of the capital structure (typically the cost of short-term debt, long-term debt, preferred stock and common equity of the utility). The overall cost of each of the elements is calculated taking into account such items as issuance costs to come up with an “effective” cost for each element. The “effective” cost of each element of the capital structure is “weighted” in proportion to its percentage in the capital structure to produce a weighted effective cost.
4 Sometimes businesses generally pay more than their cost of service and residents may pay less than the cost incurred to serve them. Thus, in a general sense, businesses subsidize residential customers. However, there is a trend to move the residential customer to paying closer to their respective costs of service.
5 Revenue requirements of a utility are in a constant state of flux and in theory a utility could operate indefinitely under the same rates if there was a growth in sales that generated sufficient revenue to cover a utilities operating expenses and/or if operating expenses or return on investment were lower than the levels used to set the current rates. Obviously, this does not happen for any given length of time and rates are generally too high or too low.
6 In choosing witnesses, the utility needs to decide whether to limit the presentation to a few good witnesses who have a broad, but not intimate, understanding of the operations and costs (since rate cases focus on numbers, and the operational witnesses may not understand the overhead component of costs in their area), or should the responsibility be spread over numerous witnesses with an intimate understanding of and hands-on expertise in the area of testimony (so that the utility can train witnesses, familiarize key employees with the numbers and offer a contrast to witnesses put on by other parties such as the consumer advocate’s witnesses). Whatever the choice, the witnesses will be involved for the entire process that may take over a year.
7 In forecasting sales, expenses and capital expenditures, the utility generally chooses between using its operating budget (which should be the utility’s best estimate of what it needs to operate economically and efficiently), or a separate rate case forecast (which could be simpler, more up to date, and easier to derive, and thereby reduce the number of revisions and facilitate the regulators understanding). Often, a compromise position has been to use an adjusted operating forecast. Interestingly, the need for more detailed, verifiable forecasts for rate cases has resulted in changes in the way some operating budgets are made for the utility’s normal operations.
8 For example, in the discovery phase of a rate case, the strategy choices include whether the utility will be litigious (i.e., file objections, respond to requests only as written, etc.) and force the other parties and/or the Commission to work to obtain data, or whether the utility will work with the other parties to avoid confusion, non-issues and delays. Not surprisingly, it appears that the cooperative utilities generally obtain better results.