July 20, 2026  |  Articles

The Pros and Cons of Hawai‘i Branding

Wooden Cutlery And Kitchen Bowls

A brand is a source identifier – it is a symbol that identifies the source, and therefore quality, of a business or its products. For a successful company, the brand of the company is often the company’s most valuable asset. For example, Pepsico owns several brands that generate more than a billion dollars of annual sales each, such as Pepsi, Gatorade, Tropicana, Lay’s and Doritos. For a successful company, the value of the brand can exceed the value of the physical assets of the company.

The brand symbolizes the reputation of the company and therefore the likelihood of future business coming to the company. This likelihood of future business is sometimes referred to as goodwill.

Formal legal names for a brand include “trademark”, “service mark” and “trade name.”

A company must protect its brand against competitors which may adopt and use brands that are so similar that people are likely to be confused into buying the competitors’ goods and services (“products”) instead of the company’s products. This likelihood of confusion is called trademark infringement.

In extreme cases, a competitor will adopt and use exactly the same brand for exactly the same products, which (if there is a federal trademark registration for that brand covering those products) is called counterfeiting.

A business may adopt and use a brand that evokes or refers to Hawai‘i. This is Hawai‘i branding. The brand could be the word “Hawai‘i”, or the name of a geographic area in Hawai‘i, like “Kona,” or a word in the Hawaiian language that is used to evoke Hawai‘i, like “Aloha.”

This article will discuss issues with Hawai‘i branding based on actual cases that have occurred, but (unfortunately) some of the best and most interesting cases cannot be discussed because they would identify firm clients.

Hawai‘i has such an attractive and positive image in the world that Hawai‘i branding is attractive to many non-Hawai‘i businesses, which want to be associated with that image to generate increased sales.

We who live in Hawai‘i are not overly sensitive to Hawai‘i branding because we live here and therefore are surrounded constantly by Hawai‘i branding by local companies.

But the sad fact is that the companies that profit the most from Hawai‘i branding are often not based in Hawai‘i, and some have no connection to Hawai‘i at all.

For example, many readers will recall that a few years ago, a Chicago based company obtained a federal trademark registration for “ALOHA POKE” and demanded that several Hawai‘i companies stop using “ALOHA POKE” (this trademark registration also blocked some Hawai‘i companies’ trademark applications). Many readers will also remember “Hawaiian Punch” fruit juice drinks, owned by Dr. Pepper/Seven-Up, Inc.

The author has spoken to several Hawai‘i trade groups and pointed out that non-Hawai‘i companies are using Hawai‘i branding and generating more profits from the use of Hawai‘i branding than Hawai‘i companies, and none of these profits benefits Hawai‘i. An industry or governmental organization might want to consider taking some kind of action, such as filing “oppositions” objecting to Hawai‘i branding by non-Hawai‘i companies or federally registering a certification mark, just as the Idaho Potato Commission (an Idaho government agency) did, when it obtained US certification mark registration 2914308 for “IDAHO” for “Potatoes and potato products, namely fresh, frozen, refrigerated and dehydrated potatoes.”

A certification mark is held by an entity that certifies that products meet certain standards, like the Underwriters Laboratory “UL” in a circle mark or the Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval.

Ul

Having Hawai‘i adopt laws regarding Hawai‘i branding by non-Hawai‘i companies would not have any effect outside Hawai‘i because Hawai‘i laws do not have any effect outside Hawai‘i. As described more fully below, other countries protect geographic designations of origin more than the US does so the major problem may be the use of Hawai‘i branding by non-Hawai‘i US Mainland companies. Thus, any action must be taken on the federal level.

The Hawai‘i State government has not sat idly by; the Hawai‘i Department of Agriculture has obtained the following US trademark registrations:

2365585 for “100% HAWAII COFFEE” and a flower design
2322867 for “100% KONA COFFEE” and a flower design
2380257 for “100% OAHU COFFEE” and a flower design
2344394 for “100% MAUI COFFEE” and a flower design
2337127 for “100% KAUAI COFFEE” and a flower design

Coffee Flowers

All of these registrations are for “coffee” and do not relate to any other goods.

The Hawai‘i Department of Agriculture also owns US trademark registration 5078416 for “MADE IN HAWAII WITH ALOHA” and a design, but this is for “Advertising and marketing services, namely, promoting the goods and services of others” and not a trademark for any particular Hawai‘i made goods.

The Hawai‘i Department of Agriculture also owns US trademark registration 3939639 for “Island Fresh Buy Local It Matters Join the Movement” and a flower, but this is not directed to Hawai‘i branding because it is for “Promoting public awareness of and product merchandising for Hawai‘i’s agricultural producers to encourage local residents to support local farmers and ranchers by making conscious decisions to purchase locally grown produce.”

The issues described below are discussed so that companies can be forewarned about complexities that can arise with adopting and using Hawai‘i branding, some of which do not arise until long after the Hawai‘i brand has been adopted so that it is then too late to avoid expensive legal problems.

One major problem with Hawai‘i branding is that it may be difficult and certainly will be more expensive, to protect against competitors stealing business through infringement and counterfeiting, both in the real world and online. But the marketing and other business value of Hawai‘i branding may make it worthwhile to adopt Hawai‘i branding anyway, despite these additional and difficulties and costs. After all, many non-Hawai‘i companies adopt Hawai‘i branding, so they apparently believe the additional difficulties and costs of doing so are worthwhile. Just be sure to expect (and budget for) these additional difficulties and costs.

“The people who benefit most from Hawai‘i branding should be the people of Hawai‘i.”

If a Hawai‘i company adopts Hawai‘i branding for its products, such as by using the name of a Hawai‘i geographic area, others in Hawai‘i who are from the same area can adopt and use the same brand. No one can claim exclusive rights to “Hawai‘i,” “Honolulu,” “‘Aiea,” or some other geographic term unless and until that geographic term has become recognized in the marketplace as a trademark (instead of just as a place name) for the specific product. Examples of geographic terms outside Hawai‘i that have achieved this recognition include Kentucky Fried Chicken, Philadelphia Cream Cheese, and California Pizza Kitchen. However, before this market recognition has been achieved (which probably would take many years and millions of dollars in sales), others from the named geographic area can use the name of that geographic area in their trademarks. No one can stop someone from truthfully describing the place where their products originate.

Another major problem with Hawai‘i branding is that it may restrict the growth of a company.

If a company has become successful in adopting and using Hawai‘i branding in Hawai‘i, the company will want to expand outside Hawai‘i. However, manufacturing and shipping products from Hawai‘i to be sold to the Mainland or Asia (the most likely target markets) is usually more expensive (than having products made locally in the target market and sold under the Hawai‘i branding.) The company may therefore choose to have the product manufactured in the target market, not in Hawai‘i. But this then creates the problem that the product is not made in Hawai‘i yet bears Hawai‘i branding. This has created lawsuits by people who assert that they were deceived into buying a product, believing it was from Hawai‘i, when it was not. This same issue arises if a Hawai‘i based company is bought by a non-Hawai‘i company and moved outside Hawai‘i – the new owner will want to continue using the Hawai‘i branding but the new owner has no connection with Hawai‘i. These kinds of situations have led to several lawsuits, including consumer class action lawsuits. Although it may be possible to win these cases, it would be extremely expensive.

Using Hawai‘i branding will also create problems in obtaining trademark registrations in Hawai‘i, the US and other countries. As explained below, federal and foreign trademark registrations are important for various reasons but Hawai‘i branding may create difficulties in obtaining such registrations.

Federal trademark registration is very important because it is required by many online retailers and courts before the most effective remedies against infringement or counterfeiting can be granted. Federal trademark registration is critically important to Hawai‘i businesses because federal trademark registrations grant rights throughout the entire United States. Foreign trademark registrations are also critically important to Hawai‘i businesses because trademark rights in the US do not extend outside the US. Merely geographic terms usually are not registrable in the US as trademarks unless and until the market recognition described above has been achieved. Many countries follow this same principle.

Sometimes businesses adopt Hawai‘i branding because the trademark they want to use belongs to someone else. For example, the desired trademark is “XYZ”, but someone else already uses “XYZ” as a trademark or already owns xyz.com. Many businesses then adopt and use “XYZ HAWAII” as a trademark, and register xyzhawaii.com as their domain name. This would NOT avoid an infringement claim by the owner of “XYZ” because customers would then be confused into believing that “XYZ HAWAII” is somehow approved, sponsored or affiliated with “XYZ.” It is very likely that the owner of “XYZ” will find out because there are no geographic limitations in cyberspace so online sales through xyzhawaii.com might result in the owner of “XYZ” filing a lawsuit, possibly somewhere on the Mainland.

Most trademark offices in the world are stricter than the US Patent and Trademark Office in allowing registration of trademarks that describe a product as being from Hawai‘i (when they actually are made somewhere else). For example, in Japan, if a trademark contains a geographic term, registration will be refused, or the registration is explicitly restricted to products from that area. This creates a problem if it is more expensive to ship products from Hawai‘i to Japan than to make products in Japan so that the company wants to make products in Japan and sell them in Japan using Hawai‘i branding.

Indeed, about 73 countries, including the European Union and Mexico, are members of the Lisbon Agreement for the Protection of Appellations of Origin and their International Registration. However, the US is NOT a member so US companies cannot seek protection of geographic terms under the Lisbon Agreement. The US has agreed to limited protection of certain geographic designations as part of international trade negotiations, which is the reason US law no longer allows the term “Champagne” to be used for sparkling wine unless that wine comes from the Champagne region of France. But US law still allows cheese to be sold as “Parmesan cheese,” even when it does not come from Italy. “Parmesan” is a protected geographic designation in Europe and can only be used in Europe for cheese from specific regions of Northern Italy.

There may also be reputational issues with adopting Hawai‘i branding. For example, a non-Hawai‘i business that adopts Hawai‘i branding may face assertions of cultural misappropriation or similar claims especially over social media.

Trademark registrations are very important in the modern economy because someone else may register a company’s Hawai‘i brand as a foreign trademark, or as a domain name, social media handle, or other designation in cyberspace. If the Hawai‘i company does not already have a trademark registration in the relevant country, then the Hawai‘i company may not be able to act against this infringement in the foreign country or in cyberspace. This is most important in cyberspace because there are no geographic boundaries in cyberspace. Most online retailers have trademark policies to prevent trademark infringement, but a company may not be able to use these policies without a federal trademark registration. Further, an online retailer may only take action against a listing with respect to buyers from a country in which a trademark registration has been obtained and leave the online listing alone for purchasers from other countries.

In one sense, it is easy for a company to protect its trademark by obtaining US and foreign trademark registrations, but in another sense it is extremely difficult. Very few attorneys practice trademarks law, and if an attorney is a sole practitioner, what will happen if that attorney retires? Who will handle the maintenance and renewal documents, which must be filed between the fifth and sixth anniversaries and every tenth anniversary for US registrations, and every tenth anniversary for most foreign registrations (with additional maintenance documents due in the Philippines and Mexico). Although the Madrid Protocol provides an international trademark registration process that makes it easier and cheaper to obtain and renew foreign trademark registrations, there are major pitfalls for the unwary.

Another complication in obtaining foreign trademark registrations is that in most foreign countries and in the US, non-use of a trademark for three years (five years in Europe) renders a trademark registration vulnerable to cancellation on the grounds of non-use. Failure to show use of the registered trademark in the relevant country for the registered products during the last three years (five years in Europe) could lead to cancellation of the registration in that country. This situation sometimes arises because a non-Hawai‘i company files a trademark application for a Hawai‘i branded trademark in a foreign country, and the application is blocked by a Hawai‘i company’s trademark registration for that trademark in that foreign country. If the Hawai‘i company cannot show actual use of its trademark for the registered products for the applicable time period in that country, then the registration may be cancelled in whole or in part.

But having foreign trademark registrations can be very important to a business that has business that extends outside Hawai‘i, such as through licensing. Licensing a trademark is basically renting the brand. However, a trademark license is merely a grant of permission to do something that, in the absence of permission, would constitute trademark infringement. If a company does not already own a trademark registration in a foreign country, it does not have the right to grant a trademark license in that foreign country and also is vulnerable to someone in that foreign country stealing the trademark and registering it. For example, Hawai‘i branded products are very popular in Japan so a product that is popular in Hawai‘i is at risk of someone in Japan stealing the trademark. More legitimate Japan companies may request a license, but if there is no Japan registration, there is nothing to license.

Thus, although Hawai‘i branding may be a viable way to proceed, a business must be aware of the issues discussed above and be willing to pay the increased legal costs that may be incurred. However, if the Hawai‘i branding is valuable enough, these increased costs may be justified. Certainly, many non-Hawai‘i companies believe that Hawai‘i branding is valuable enough. Hawai‘i companies should make their own judgments. After all, the people who benefit most from Hawai‘i branding should be the people of Hawai‘i.